In this strongly worded essay, Peter Kwasniewski (writing under Big Modernism / Hiraeth In Exile) argues that the Vatican under Pope Leo XIV is engaged in a “long con” regarding Holy Orders — giving the appearance of orthodoxy while keeping the door open for future changes, particularly on women deacons
Dr. Peter Kwasniewski, a serious and well-reasoned traditional Catholic thinker, offers a sharp critique of the latest Vatican document on the diaconate. He contends that while the commission gives a temporary “no” to women deacons, it deliberately avoids a definitive, permanent ruling and leaves room for future “development.”
Kwasniewski sees this as part of a broader pattern: using endless study commissions, ambiguous language, and non-definitive statements to slowly shift the Church away from clear Tradition on the male-only nature of Holy Orders.
Our Approach to This Piece: This is one of those voices in the traditional Catholic world that we should monitor carefully. Kwasniewski is an intelligent, historically informed writer who often raises important concerns. However, readers should approach his analysis with discernment — some of his strongest claims rely on interpretive judgment about motives and long-term strategy rather than undisputed facts. Like much commentary in this space, it carries a sense of urgency that can appeal to fear and frustration among faithful Catholics.
That said, the core issue he raises — whether the Church is truly closing the door on women deacons or merely delaying the question — is legitimate and deserves ongoing attention.
Read the full essay here (Note: The article is from Big Modernism / Hiraeth In Exile)